Monday, December 19, 2016

predict the future?

I believe any prediction of the future is about here and now. And I don’t think the world is gonna change THAT much in 25 years.

1.
Among the three alternative worlds proposed by Fracer and Sandford I’m most interested in the first one – Trust Yourself. In this scenario people take full responsibility for their choices and bear little social allegiances. Education is highly personalized, with a wide range of options.
Technology has made educational resources more accessible than ever, which lays the foundation for this scenario. Today we can basically find everything we want to learn just sitting in bed typing into a search bar – tutorial videos, digitalized books, or even course syllabus from Harvard Law School. No need to walk to the library or meet up with a professor – well not physically but that library might have all their collections online, and that expert might have listed all her past and present works. We never have to be “stuck” with one major, one job, or one profession like people used to be. Want to be a professional programmer? Go Codeacademy and start from scratch and there are plenty of kind people who’d love to have a look at your rudimentary codes. Choices are just right there, at our fingertips, as long as we take advantage of them. Problem is that we might need to learn first about how to learn and how to gather sources from scattered platforms.

2. However, who’s taking responsibility for kids’ actions? Their legal guardians? I can’t imagine a scenario where my parents chose for me whatever they believed I need to learn, though they both went to college. Before people have the ability to account for their decisions, or even the ability to make a decision, compulsory education still serves as a helpful first-step. I have not given up on “society” just yet, and the ideological function of education wont let go as long as the concept of “nation state” subsists (especially when recent events keep reminding us how isolated and intolerant we are).
Society should still provide for instructions of basic facts and skills, and prepare students for a more individualized system. They should encourage diversity within the framework, and nurture the interest in life-long learning.


3. Interdisciplinary education is another possible path. Reforms are already taking places in various places. Beijing will cancel the split of “students of humanities” and ”students of sciences” in college entrance exam (yep its kinda late but at least on the right track), and Finland will incorporate phenomenon-based learning into school syllabus. Learning and teaching will be more problem-oriented than subject-oriented.  

Sunday, November 20, 2016

work progress weekly

    This week I started collecting my samples of content analysis. So far I have been sticking to my previous design of sampling- search tags of character pairs on Tumblr and select the most popular 30 fan-arts. For now it works but after I start the actual coding I might change the method and start over again (just bare it in mind).
    I continued to read about visual content analysis and have familiarise myself with basic concepts of such analysis research – after deciding the scale of content, I need to define “observable dimensions (variables) of the images in question as well as a judgement about how frequently various visual features appear”. Variables and values are the crucial next stop.
    Some variables that I can think of now: pose of represented characters (their relationship; how powerful they are, their head-body disposition); setting context (home bathroom kitchen outdoor automobile or original); visual modality (absence of detail to maximal representation of detail); role (domestic or public), size of representation…

    I know I will moderate the variables so next week I’ll look into more fan-fiction researches to see common dimensions especially regarding to my concern of homosexual stereotyping. 

Saturday, November 12, 2016

final project-week1

    For my final project I will explore homosexual stereotyping in fan-arts and related topics include image analysis, homosexual stereotype and online fandom community.

    I started from my article review for the article I chose is of similar interest and I looked up a couple of studies, featuring gay stereotype or image analysis. I found the research Four Decades of Images in Gay Male-targeted Magazines very helpful. It introduces the method of content analysis and points out a particular feature of images of male body (especially gay men): masculinity and body fat. I am considering add this as one of my parameters for fan-art analysis but one concern is that fanarts are in the form of painting, which might not match the same standards of photos. I have read some other studies of image analysis from magazines but I think I also need to look for resources from more relevant platforms (online) and forms (paintings or designed image instead of photo).


    For methodology, I checked out evivo, one powerful software for content analysis in qualitative researches. I watched some video tutorials on how to code an image and I believe it would be a very helpful tool for my project. Next week Ill continue with the software while looking for more researches using open-coding to structure qualitative data.

Thursday, October 27, 2016

new media and body objectification

Q.Do you think the increasingly image-driven nature of the web is contributing to body objectification? Did the author give a historical perspective that would have extended back to a time when images were less commonplace?
(The article I worked on:‘Shouldn’t Tom Daley be a bottom’: Homosexual Stereotyping Online by Joseph Brennan)

First I’d like to thank everyone for being there! And those interesting & insightful questions!

    Yes I agree that the increasingly image-driven nature of the web exacerbate the problem of body objectification. Well the author does not provide historical records from before the “image era” but I would assume that at that time if people were more used to looking at real persons in real life rather than photoshoped supermodels they would have less “objectified” opinions on body images. (I’m not saying that it didn’t exist. Even a folktale might describe a “fair maiden” with certain physical characteristics but words leave more flexibility for imagination than concrete images.)
    One research in the article’s literature review points out that male-gay-targeted magazines constantly display “ideal” body images with “low body fat and high masculinity” and discovers notable increase in the frequency of such images from 1967 to 2008. Actually with the development of mass media - newspaper, magazine, television, film and now internet, the problem has always been around and has been getting worse. We have been exposed to those beautiful bodies screaming at us: THIS is the ideal that EVERYONE should be pursuing and if you don’t have/want a body like that SHAME on you. Internet and social media just make them even more ubiquitous and personal. We are all showing our bodies on social media, which makes us more self-conscious.
     However the democratic aspect of web-based media also brings in diversity and different voices. For example, some beauty bloggers are posting pictures without makeup to reveal the “truth” and have received positive feedback. And the body positive movement (for a more tolerating attitude towards body images), also takes advantage of social media to spread the idea. True, our media is reinforcing body objectification, but it is also the weapon to fight back?

Sunday, October 2, 2016

Further on the identity-construction on social media

Last week we had a prolonged discussion over the two lives, online and offline, and already touched upon the identity issue. However, I noticed that I somehow have drawn contradictory conclusions when explaining for the online identity - sometimes I think second life enables false-representation (e.g. people pretend to be Indians) but sometimes it reveals the “real” self which is suppressed in real life (e.g. people make offences which they would not dare unless offline). I mentioned in my last blog that there are many aspects of “self” but it was merely a rough idea.

This week’s readings have further explored the topic of identity-making on social media, especially on social network sites. The multimodal approach happens to address to my question and helps me clarify the confusion mentioned above. Actually the non-essentialist explanation of identity has been around for at least two centuries in philosophy and literature criticism that Marx has commented “the essence of man…is the ensemble of the social relations.” To view identity in the context of social relations is nothing new but when it comes to the relatively new domain - identity analysis in social media- we seem to inevitably fall into the duality of two selves again before we pick up the social-constructed and constant-evolving multiple identities.

The duality of online and offline might have been sufficient before, but not in this age. The sharp distinction between online/offline spheres, which was the preposition of the duality approach, has been destroyed as social media is no longer the “second life” but PART of the life itself. Our activities online have been integrated into the “real life” and serve as one kind of social interactions which contribute to the general identity construction process.


However, the two examples presented in that article, Facebook and Enterprise Social Networking, are both deeply rooted in the real social life that we use real names and information and interact with people we are likely to know in person. I am wondering if it works the same way in a more anonymous context (or “social media” simply excludes anonymous web-based platforms?). What if I didn’t want to “reflect over my life” or “narrate my community story” but just to make things up? 

Monday, September 26, 2016

Online identities and building new social norms in cyberworld

Even from our personal experience with social networking sites, we could tell how natural it is for us to build an “online self” that is somehow different from the real world us. In that sense the life online is detached from the reality. At the same time, the online interactions without a doubt are changing our social relations offline. We can see the two layers of life are closely intertwined.

In Understanding the Functional Blocks of Social Media, the emphasis is put on the interaction between SNS discussion and real life business. The example of “United Breaks Guitars”, surely demonstrates the impact of SNS discussion on brands’ reputation, but it also points out some overlooked real life problems – damaged luggage should be included in airlines policies and the procedure should be clear in compliance to consumer-protection laws. The fact that people feel the need to seek attention online reveals that real life rules and protocols are not functioning well. In that case, online discussion serves as a positive complement to

Back to the two-layer life idea. Here we might want to separate two kinds of online activities, those related to real life identities and those with anonymity. For the first kind, although real life information is involved, online identity can be very much constructed and manipulated. We build different identities for ourselves by tailoring our profiles based on the context of the sites, each representing some aspect of ourselves. False representation, exaggeration, distortion, or more often, intentional selection of information, all weave into the personas we are wearing in our life in the cloud. It seems that online identities are separated from the real world.


However, online environment provides the ease of anonymity and the detachment from social norms, which might as well maximise certain sides of ourselves that we choose to hide in daily social interactions. As suggested in Second Thoughts about Second Life, the vice of humanity can be brought out in the virtual world due to lack of regulation. In everyday life we are used to conform to all kinds of rules, but in the virtual world, moral system and legal guidance are yet to be developed. It also acts on users’ psychology in that they might tend to violate socially acceptable behaviour online if they believe they can get away. If we examine the violations and offences online, we wont be surprised that many of them are of the same nature as real life crimes. The boundaries between reality and simulation are always blurred, as participants are still real human beings experiencing real emotions. Therefore, many of our rules and protocols could still apply to online situations, provided that we bear in mind the new context.

Tuesday, September 20, 2016

Thoughts on the report Media Conversations About Race

I have always been interested in the role of social media in reflecting and shaping social norms and the report Media Conversations About Race on Pew Research Center caught my attention. (http://www.pewinternet.org/2016/08/15/social-media-conversations-about-race/)

They present some interesting findings
-Black people are reported to be twice likely to see and to post racial-related content on SNS (social network sites) despite the fact that only 0.04% of all tweets in 2015 were race-related.
-More than half of race-related tweets are in reaction to current news events, and the general attitude on SNS could change overnight.
-Race-related hashtags (#Ferguson and #BlackLivesMatter) top in the most-used social cause hashtags and are used to promote social movements.

It is no surprise that African American social media users are in general more involved in race-related discussion online since they are among the “disadvantaged” group. However, I am also intrigued by the fact that when public media starts a conversation about racial discrimination, African American as a group has earned much more attention than other racial minorities like Asian population. According to Wikipedia, in the 2010 US census, 12.6% of American population are black and 4.8% Asian. African American group is admittedly the largest racial minority but other racial groups have far less media representation than they deserve in proportion to their population. The survey count Hispanic/Latino population as separated groups but it could be misleading since Hispanic/Latino origin refers to ethnicity rather than race.

This exemplifies the idea from last week’s reading that technology and social relations are mutually constituted. On one hand, social relations determines how we use technology and for what purpose. On the other, technology redefines our understanding about social relations. The ubiquitous internet, mobile devices and social media sites have revolutionized the way media affects society and individual life - social media has become the major source of news and public space for personal opinions and individuals are paying a more active role to participate in the events rather than passively receive information. A collective voice may be easier to be heard but more than often we tend to forget what we think we see is not necessarily what it is. The “reality” created by online discussion and media representation may somehow overshadow the reality in real life (if there is any), as over/underestimation has always been a risk. The relevant silence/lack of representation of other racial groups simply pushes them into a more disadvantaged condition that their problems pass unseen.