Thursday, October 27, 2016

new media and body objectification

Q.Do you think the increasingly image-driven nature of the web is contributing to body objectification? Did the author give a historical perspective that would have extended back to a time when images were less commonplace?
(The article I worked on:‘Shouldn’t Tom Daley be a bottom’: Homosexual Stereotyping Online by Joseph Brennan)

First I’d like to thank everyone for being there! And those interesting & insightful questions!

    Yes I agree that the increasingly image-driven nature of the web exacerbate the problem of body objectification. Well the author does not provide historical records from before the “image era” but I would assume that at that time if people were more used to looking at real persons in real life rather than photoshoped supermodels they would have less “objectified” opinions on body images. (I’m not saying that it didn’t exist. Even a folktale might describe a “fair maiden” with certain physical characteristics but words leave more flexibility for imagination than concrete images.)
    One research in the article’s literature review points out that male-gay-targeted magazines constantly display “ideal” body images with “low body fat and high masculinity” and discovers notable increase in the frequency of such images from 1967 to 2008. Actually with the development of mass media - newspaper, magazine, television, film and now internet, the problem has always been around and has been getting worse. We have been exposed to those beautiful bodies screaming at us: THIS is the ideal that EVERYONE should be pursuing and if you don’t have/want a body like that SHAME on you. Internet and social media just make them even more ubiquitous and personal. We are all showing our bodies on social media, which makes us more self-conscious.
     However the democratic aspect of web-based media also brings in diversity and different voices. For example, some beauty bloggers are posting pictures without makeup to reveal the “truth” and have received positive feedback. And the body positive movement (for a more tolerating attitude towards body images), also takes advantage of social media to spread the idea. True, our media is reinforcing body objectification, but it is also the weapon to fight back?

Sunday, October 2, 2016

Further on the identity-construction on social media

Last week we had a prolonged discussion over the two lives, online and offline, and already touched upon the identity issue. However, I noticed that I somehow have drawn contradictory conclusions when explaining for the online identity - sometimes I think second life enables false-representation (e.g. people pretend to be Indians) but sometimes it reveals the “real” self which is suppressed in real life (e.g. people make offences which they would not dare unless offline). I mentioned in my last blog that there are many aspects of “self” but it was merely a rough idea.

This week’s readings have further explored the topic of identity-making on social media, especially on social network sites. The multimodal approach happens to address to my question and helps me clarify the confusion mentioned above. Actually the non-essentialist explanation of identity has been around for at least two centuries in philosophy and literature criticism that Marx has commented “the essence of man…is the ensemble of the social relations.” To view identity in the context of social relations is nothing new but when it comes to the relatively new domain - identity analysis in social media- we seem to inevitably fall into the duality of two selves again before we pick up the social-constructed and constant-evolving multiple identities.

The duality of online and offline might have been sufficient before, but not in this age. The sharp distinction between online/offline spheres, which was the preposition of the duality approach, has been destroyed as social media is no longer the “second life” but PART of the life itself. Our activities online have been integrated into the “real life” and serve as one kind of social interactions which contribute to the general identity construction process.


However, the two examples presented in that article, Facebook and Enterprise Social Networking, are both deeply rooted in the real social life that we use real names and information and interact with people we are likely to know in person. I am wondering if it works the same way in a more anonymous context (or “social media” simply excludes anonymous web-based platforms?). What if I didn’t want to “reflect over my life” or “narrate my community story” but just to make things up?