Monday, September 26, 2016

Online identities and building new social norms in cyberworld

Even from our personal experience with social networking sites, we could tell how natural it is for us to build an “online self” that is somehow different from the real world us. In that sense the life online is detached from the reality. At the same time, the online interactions without a doubt are changing our social relations offline. We can see the two layers of life are closely intertwined.

In Understanding the Functional Blocks of Social Media, the emphasis is put on the interaction between SNS discussion and real life business. The example of “United Breaks Guitars”, surely demonstrates the impact of SNS discussion on brands’ reputation, but it also points out some overlooked real life problems – damaged luggage should be included in airlines policies and the procedure should be clear in compliance to consumer-protection laws. The fact that people feel the need to seek attention online reveals that real life rules and protocols are not functioning well. In that case, online discussion serves as a positive complement to

Back to the two-layer life idea. Here we might want to separate two kinds of online activities, those related to real life identities and those with anonymity. For the first kind, although real life information is involved, online identity can be very much constructed and manipulated. We build different identities for ourselves by tailoring our profiles based on the context of the sites, each representing some aspect of ourselves. False representation, exaggeration, distortion, or more often, intentional selection of information, all weave into the personas we are wearing in our life in the cloud. It seems that online identities are separated from the real world.


However, online environment provides the ease of anonymity and the detachment from social norms, which might as well maximise certain sides of ourselves that we choose to hide in daily social interactions. As suggested in Second Thoughts about Second Life, the vice of humanity can be brought out in the virtual world due to lack of regulation. In everyday life we are used to conform to all kinds of rules, but in the virtual world, moral system and legal guidance are yet to be developed. It also acts on users’ psychology in that they might tend to violate socially acceptable behaviour online if they believe they can get away. If we examine the violations and offences online, we wont be surprised that many of them are of the same nature as real life crimes. The boundaries between reality and simulation are always blurred, as participants are still real human beings experiencing real emotions. Therefore, many of our rules and protocols could still apply to online situations, provided that we bear in mind the new context.

Tuesday, September 20, 2016

Thoughts on the report Media Conversations About Race

I have always been interested in the role of social media in reflecting and shaping social norms and the report Media Conversations About Race on Pew Research Center caught my attention. (http://www.pewinternet.org/2016/08/15/social-media-conversations-about-race/)

They present some interesting findings
-Black people are reported to be twice likely to see and to post racial-related content on SNS (social network sites) despite the fact that only 0.04% of all tweets in 2015 were race-related.
-More than half of race-related tweets are in reaction to current news events, and the general attitude on SNS could change overnight.
-Race-related hashtags (#Ferguson and #BlackLivesMatter) top in the most-used social cause hashtags and are used to promote social movements.

It is no surprise that African American social media users are in general more involved in race-related discussion online since they are among the “disadvantaged” group. However, I am also intrigued by the fact that when public media starts a conversation about racial discrimination, African American as a group has earned much more attention than other racial minorities like Asian population. According to Wikipedia, in the 2010 US census, 12.6% of American population are black and 4.8% Asian. African American group is admittedly the largest racial minority but other racial groups have far less media representation than they deserve in proportion to their population. The survey count Hispanic/Latino population as separated groups but it could be misleading since Hispanic/Latino origin refers to ethnicity rather than race.

This exemplifies the idea from last week’s reading that technology and social relations are mutually constituted. On one hand, social relations determines how we use technology and for what purpose. On the other, technology redefines our understanding about social relations. The ubiquitous internet, mobile devices and social media sites have revolutionized the way media affects society and individual life - social media has become the major source of news and public space for personal opinions and individuals are paying a more active role to participate in the events rather than passively receive information. A collective voice may be easier to be heard but more than often we tend to forget what we think we see is not necessarily what it is. The “reality” created by online discussion and media representation may somehow overshadow the reality in real life (if there is any), as over/underestimation has always been a risk. The relevant silence/lack of representation of other racial groups simply pushes them into a more disadvantaged condition that their problems pass unseen.


Tuesday, September 13, 2016

On Tinder for 5 days

Inspired by last week’s discussion over online communities, I decided to explore a new app – Tinder (at least new to me!) and recorded my experience as the first post of our course blog.

For those who are not familiar with the app, I will briefly explain the mechanism. Tinder is a mobile dating/hook-up app, where you link it to your Facebook account, upload pictures, write a short bio and then happy hunting! You will be shown the profiles of other users, within your choice of gender, distance and age. Swipe left means “no” and swipe right means “like”. When both people swipe right for each other, you become a “match” and may start a conversation.

For five days I went through about 250 profiles, swiped right 27 times and got 21 matches (most discussions online confirm that on Tinder men are much more generous with their “likes” than women, which aligns our traditional expectation for gender roles in romantic relationships.) Only 7 out of 21 initiated conversation and I replied 3 of them.

Obviously profile pictures are the key, since many of us are all too visual to read the bio first, if we read at all. Tinder allows users to upload up to six pictures, and according to my results I find that I tended to swipe right for people with at least four pictures. It was not an intentional choice but with more profile pictures I was offered more perspectives of their lives, and of course a better description of their faces. Beside the regular headshots, selfies and full-length photos, the most common kinds of pictures for men (based on my rough summary of 50 profiles) always feature them travelling, doing sports, holding children or animals, wearing suits and partying with friends.  One interesting point that has caught my attention is people’s passion for the city – quite a many use photos with New York skylines and streets as backgrounds. The popular genres of photos may shed light on the “desired qualities” that people usually seek from men as potential dates – athletic, open-minded, friendly, capable and sociable.  

Not until I am on Tinder have I realized how “picky” I could be. For me, the simple action of swiping seems to be one of the most diminishing way to crush human dignity – in less than a second we would label one of our fellow human beings as “not worth my time” based on one picture of them. Here, living people are totally replaceable because we know there is the almost endless list of potential choices, especially in New York.

One anecdote: I saw someone I knew in real life (from our program actually) and was stuck on whether to swipe right out of courtesy or to swipe left to avoid embarrassment. I suppose it is not uncommon to come across acquaintances on Tinder but seriously what do people do??